Blue Jay All-Americans:
- 1962: Linda Eshelman
- 1982: Edith Thompson
- 1985: Bonnie Bair
- 1986: Bonnie Bair
- 1986: Laura West
- 1987: Teresa Moats
- 1988: Teresa Moats
- 1995: Heidi Balmer
- 2005: Mel Slessinger
Blue Jay All-Region Players:
- 1964: Louise Wenger (2nd Team)
- 1982: Edith Thompson (1st Team)
- 1987: Cheryl Charles (1st Team)
- 1987: Teresa Moats (1st Team)
- 1987: Monica Esh (2nd Team)
- 1988: Teresa Moats (1st Team)
- 1994: Heidi Balmer (2nd Team)
- 1994: Arlisa Snavely (2nd Team)
- 1995: Heidi Balmer (1st Team)
- 1997: Lora Crawford (2nd Team)
- 1998: Mandi Ewing (2nd Team)
- 1998: Denise Heller (2nd Team)
- 2000: Mandi Ewing (1st Team)
- 2000: Mindy Nace (2nd Team)
- 2002: Brandy Espenshade (2nd Team)
- 2002: Mindy Nace (2nd Team)
- 2003: Kate Gwilliam (2nd Team)
- 2005: Mel Slessinger (1st Team)
NFHCA Senior All-Star Game Participants:
- 1998: Denise Heller
- 2000: Mandi Ewing
- 2002: Brandy Espenshade
Ira R. Herr Hall of Fame Members:
- 1975: Linda Eshelman Hopple '63
- 1977: Louise Wenger Girvin '65
- 1984: Sharon Holtzapple '76
- 1985: Nancy Ferguson '74
- 1986: Marion Gerner '73
- 1988: Joan Albright Lobach '80
- 1989: The 1961 Team
- 1992: Gerri Gray Thrasher '73
- 1997: Bonnie Bair '86
- 1998: Pat Moyer '70
- 2001: Teresa Moats Steinfatt '89
- 2002: Janet Strickler Evans '70
- 2003: Martha Eppley '62
- 2004: Edith Thompson '83
- 2005: Lorrie Fisher '80