• 1960: Carroll Hershey (Honorable Mention)
• 1960: Warner Cheeks (Honorable Mention)
• 1961: Frank Seltzer (Honorable Mention)
• 1962: Al Hershey (Second Team)
• 1963: Al Hershey (First Team)
• 1964: Ray Stern (Honorable Mention)
• 1967: Rick Wenger (Honorable Mention)
• 1969: Mike Yassim (First Team)
• 1971: Dave Good (Honorable Mention)
• 1973: Mohammed Daramy (Honorable Mention)
• 1975: James O'Donnell (Honorable Mention)
• 1977: James O'Donnell (Second Team)
• 1984: Shannon Perry (Third Team)
• 1985: Dave Jones (First Team)
• 1985: Shannon Perry (Second Team)
• 1985: Doug Peters (Third Team)
• 1988: Matt Saia (First Team)
• 1988: Scott Ravert (Second Team)
• 1988: Jay Varrato (Second Team)
• 1989: Robbie Martin (First Team)
• 1990: Robbie Martin (First Team)
• 1990: Jay Varrato (First Team)
• 1990: Chris Morgan (Second Team)
• 1991: Tim Jones (Second Team)
• 1992: Eric Smith (First Team)
• 1992: Pat Walsh (Third Team)
• 1994: George Crampton (Third Team)
• 1995: Doug Hess (First Team)
• 1996: Bryan Green (Second Team)
• 2000: Bryan Hoy (Third Team)
• 2002: Brad Confer (Third Team)
• 2005: Brian Healy (Third Team)

Blue Jay Academic All-Americans:

• 1984: Duane Snavely (First Team)
• 1985: Duane Snavely (Second Team)
• 1991: Jay Varrato (First Team)

Ira R. Herr Hall of Fame Members:

• 1975: Guy Buch '45
• 1975: Joel Chase '67
• 1975: Warner Cheeks '61
• 1975: Ray Diener '65
• 1975: William Foster '54
• 1975: Alvin Hershey '64
• 1975: Frank Keath '49
• 1976: Harvey Jacobs, Jr. '55
• 1976: Tony McGlaughlin '66
• 1977: Raymond Stern '65
• 1978: Carroll Hershey '61
• 1979: Gene Wise '59
• 1980: Ellwood Kerkeslager '62
• 1980: Frederick Seltzer '63
• 1981: Stanley Disney '41
• 1981: Robert Wert '47
• 1982: Arthur "Skip" Roderick, III '74
• 1983: Richard Wenger '69
• 1984: Emory Stouffer '41
• 1985: David Good '72
• 1985: Nelson Kline '53
• 1986: K. Michael Yassim '73
• 1987: Ronald Good '68
• 1989: William Hoar '60
• 1990: Herb Fenstermacher '69
• 1991: Phillip Good '79
• 1991: Franklin Zimmerman '64
• 1992: Dave Bender '69
• 1993: Arthur Kline '70
• 1995: Gary Danielson '67
• 1996: Terry Myer '72
• 1997: Gary Messinger '67
• 1998: Jay Varrato '91
• 1999: 1989 National Championship Team
• 2000: 1960 National Championship Team
• 2000: John "Jack" Ferich '56
• 2001: Steven Hassinger '75
• 2002: Bruce Jacobs '73
• 2003: Robbie Martin '91
• 2004: Shannon Perry '87
• 2005: David Jones '86
• 2006: William Kepner, Jr. '71
• 2006: Matt Saia, '89