Elizabethtown College Swimming All-Americans and Academic All-Americans

Blue Jay All-Americans:

• 1969-70: David Anstine (m)
• 1969-70: James Gingerich (m)
• 1969-70: Robert Sahms (m)
• 1969-70: Donald Schaeberle (m)
• 1970-71: David Anstine (m)
• 1970-71: Robert Sahms (m)
• 1985-86: David Parry (m)
• 1995-96: Jackie Zimmerman (w)
• 1996-97: Jackie Zimmerman (w)
• 1997-98: Jackie Zimmerman (w)
• 1998-99: Jackie Zimmerman (w)
• 2000-01: Casey Moore (m)

Blue Jay Academic All-Americans:

• 1988-89: Sharon Ulrich (w)

Blue Jay MASCAC Scholar-Athletes:

• 2006-07: Geoff Betz (m)
• 2007-08: Dan McGuigan (m)